Chief complaint or ID line is clearly stated in the opening line
SOAP / Conference format only: HPI is written as a chronological prose narrative with at least one timeline marker (e.g. "2 hours prior to presentation"); skip for Brief Rounds
Brief Rounds format only: ID line present; interval events / current status documented; active problems listed; plan-by-problem present; full HPI and examination sections are not required
Vital signs are present and physiologically plausible
Vital signs are internally consistent with the diagnosis (allowing for clinical variability — bradycardic shock, medication-blunted tachycardia, afebrile pneumonia, early STEMI with normal troponin, etc.)
Assessment contains a clearly stated primary diagnosis
Plan is present and directly addresses the primary diagnosis
If the plan includes medications: a prescribing-safety block is present before drug recommendations, confirming known inputs (allergies, renal/hepatic function, anticoagulants) and calling out unknowns (weight, bleeding risk, pregnancy); doses defer to "per local formulary/protocol" when key variables are missing
Medication plan is labelled as educational/simulated — not a substitute for clinician judgment
No real patient identifiers (direct or indirect): no names, MRNs, exact dates, locations, images, rare condition combos, occupation details, or verbatim stories from real cases
All data is synthetic, de-identified, or clearly fictional
If based on a real case, apply formal de-identification before use
HTML renders without errors in a browser
All major sections tagged with data-od-id
P1 — Should Pass
Past medical history includes conditions relevant to the presentation
Medications list is present
Physical examination findings are organised by system
Differential diagnosis contains 3 to 5 items
Each differential item includes one sentence of supporting or refuting evidence
Lab values use correct units and are within realistic ranges for the diagnosis
Plan is specific — drug names, doses, routes, and frequencies are written out where safety inputs are known; unknown variables defer to "per local formulary/protocol"
Plan is organised by problem using numbered headers
Critical findings are visually highlighted (red callout box)
Document is print-friendly (white background, @media print rules present)
A validated risk score is included where applicable (TIMI, GRACE, Killip class + Shock Index for STEMI/cardiogenic shock, CURB-65, qSOFA, Wells)
P2 — Nice to Have
Pertinent negatives documented in HPI and Review of Systems
Imaging findings described in investigations section
Specialist consult noted where clinically indicated
Disposition or follow-up plan included
Monitoring parameters specified (e.g. repeat troponin at 3h and 6h)
Secondary prevention addressed for chronic disease presentations