references/severity-matrix.md

GitHub

Severity Decision Matrix

Reference content for the offensive-osint skill. Originally §40 of the monolithic SKILL.md (refactored 2026-05-02 for size/load efficiency).

40. Severity Decision Matrix — Worked Examples

When in doubt, anchor on these worked examples (drawn from real engagements):

Finding Severity Why
/.git/config reachable on prod webapp CRITICAL Full source-code disclosure; secret history reconstructable.
/.env reachable on prod webapp CRITICAL Plaintext creds (DB, cloud, API).
Open Firebase RTDB returning data CRITICAL All app data readable; often writable.
Listable S3 bucket containing PII CRITICAL Direct data exfil.
Listable S3 bucket containing logs only HIGH Internal hostnames + paths in logs; pivot data.
Spring Boot /actuator/env exposed CRITICAL DB creds, JWT secrets, cloud keys in env.
Spring Boot /actuator/heapdump exposed CRITICAL Heap contains live secrets in string form.
Open Elasticsearch (/_cat/indices returns) CRITICAL Full data reads; often writable.
Open MongoDB (no auth) CRITICAL Full data + password-hash collection.
Open Redis (no AUTH) CRITICAL Write authorized_keys → SSH foothold.
Open Docker API (port 2375) CRITICAL Container/host takeover.
Public PMAK validated live with broad scope CRITICAL Full Postman account + all team workspaces.
Public AWS root access key validated live CRITICAL Full account compromise.
Live AWS IAM-user key found on GitHub HIGH Limited scope (depends on IAM policy); often elevatable.
Live GitHub PAT found in JS bundle HIGH Repo write access (depends on scope).
Live Slack token in pastebin HIGH Workspace data + history; sometimes channel post.
Sourcemap (.js.map) accessible on prod HIGH Frontend source disclosure.
Open GraphQL introspection on prod HIGH Full schema → mutations + business-logic discovery.
Subdomain takeover possible (Heroku / GitHub Pages / etc.) HIGH Takeover → phishing on trusted domain.
Reflected CORS with credentials on /api/billing HIGH CSRF-via-CORS for billing data.
Verb tampering: DELETE allowed on documented-GET-only endpoint HIGH Authz bypass; potentially destructive.
phpinfo.php reachable on prod HIGH Discloses paths, env vars, modules → vuln-version pivot.
Tomcat /manager/html reachable HIGH Often default creds; WAR upload = RCE.
Jenkins script console accessible HIGH Groovy script execution = RCE.
Missing HSTS on /login HIGH (escalated from MED) Login pages must enforce HSTS.
Missing HSTS on standard pages MEDIUM Hardening gap.
Missing CSP MEDIUM XSS impact mitigation gone.
Internal IP / K8s service DNS in JS MEDIUM Internal topology disclosure.
Apache /server-status reachable MEDIUM Live request visibility.
android:debuggable=true on prod app CRITICAL Production debug-build → full client compromise.
android:allowBackup=true (no whitelist) MEDIUM App data exfil via adb backup.
android:usesCleartextTraffic=true MEDIUM MITM-able on hostile networks.
Sensitive deep-link handler (myapp://reset-password) HIGH Other apps can trigger sensitive flows.
Exported Android component without permission MEDIUM IPC attack surface.
Slack webhook URL leaked MEDIUM Send to channel; can be used for social-eng.
Twilio Account SID leaked (no auth token) MEDIUM Half a credential pair; plus account enumeration.
Wildcard CORS on data-returning API MEDIUM Lower than reflected+creds but still exfil-able.
Missing X-Frame-Options LOW Clickjacking.
.DS_Store exposed LOW Directory listing of dev's machine.
Stripe test key leaked LOW No real money risk.
Firebase URL exposed (no open RTDB) LOW Project-ID disclosure only.
Cert pinning missing in mobile app LOW MITM possible on hostile networks.
Outdated WordPress install detected LOW Pending CVE confirmation.
Missing Referrer-Policy / Permissions-Policy INFO Hardening, not an exposure.
/.well-known/security.txt discovered INFO Useful contact info only.
Domain in breach with 0 named accounts INFO Contextual only.
Private bucket exists (HEAD 403) INFO Asset only, no finding.
Open kubelet on 10250 CRITICAL Pod exec without K8s API auth.
Open etcd on 2379 CRITICAL Cluster state + secrets.
K8s API on 6443 with anonymous-auth HIGH Cluster recon; sometimes pod exec.
K8s dashboard exposed without auth HIGH Cluster admin UI.
Helm Tiller (Helm 2) on 44134 HIGH Cluster-admin scope.
Citrix Netscaler with KEV CVE CRITICAL Patch immediately; actively exploited.
F5 BIG-IP TMUI accessible HIGH TMUI = admin panel; CVE-2022-1388 if unpatched = CRIT.
Pulse Secure with CVE-2024-21887 CRITICAL KEV; chained command injection.
FortiGate with CVE-2024-21762 CRITICAL KEV; auth bypass + RCE.
PaloAlto GlobalProtect with CVE-2024-3400 CRITICAL KEV; pre-auth RCE.
VMware vCenter with CVE-2021-21972 CRITICAL KEV; pre-auth RCE.
VMware ESXi exposed without VPN HIGH Multiple CVEs (ESXiArgs ransomware vector).
MS Exchange with ProxyShell/Logon/NotShell unpatched CRITICAL KEV chain; RCE + mailbox dump.
AWS Lambda Function URL accessible anonymously HIGH Direct invocation; check IAM auth posture.
Public Cloud Run / Cloud Function unauthenticated HIGH Same.
Public Docker registry (anonymous catalog) MEDIUM Image enum + secret hunt in layers.
GitHub Actions secrets echoed in workflow logs HIGH Secret-in-log = full secret disclosure.
GitHub Actions pull_request_target checkout of fork code HIGH Class of bug; secrets accessible to attacker PRs.
GitLab self-hosted with CVE-2021-22205 CRITICAL KEV; ExifTool RCE.
Jenkins with pull_request_target-equivalent misconfig HIGH Build secrets accessible to PRs.
Public Notion page with internal SOPs MEDIUM Operational intel; sometimes credentials.
Public Trello board with credentials in cards HIGH Often plaintext API keys.
Public Confluence space with onboarding docs MEDIUM Seed creds + tech-stack reveal.
Public Miro board with architecture diagrams LOW Internal-host disclosure.
DMARC policy p=none on production sending domain MEDIUM Spoof feasible (escalated from LOW for risk surface).
SPF ~all (softfail) without strict DMARC MEDIUM Spoofs land in spam, but land.
MX server allows open relay (test with 250 OK to RCPT TO foreign domain) HIGH Spam + spoof feasibility.
Live Anthropic / OpenAI API key with broad scope CRITICAL Quota cost + potential PII in past responses.
Live npm token with publish scope CRITICAL Supply-chain compromise of all maintained packages.
Live PyPI / Docker Hub / GHCR token with publish scope CRITICAL Supply-chain compromise.
Atlassian token with admin scope HIGH Workspace-wide read; sometimes write.
Subdomain takeover candidate confirmed HIGH Trusted-domain phishing surface.
Sensitive CI/CD wordlist hits (Jenkinsfile, .gitlab-ci.yml on public repo) MEDIUM Build-script intel; often references secret names.
Public Postman workspace with internal API endpoints MEDIUM API attack surface mapped.
WAF/CDN trivially bypassable (origin discoverable via §16.15) HIGH All WAF protections null.
TLS 1.0/1.1 supported on prod MEDIUM Compliance gap; PCI-DSS forbids TLS 1.0.
RC4 / 3DES cipher accepted MEDIUM NOMORE / SWEET32 attacks.
Cert about to expire (<30 days) LOW Operational risk; not exploitable.
Self-signed cert on prod MEDIUM Trust failure for users.
Heartbleed (CVE-2014-0160) detected CRITICAL Memory disclosure including session tokens + keys.
Public Slack invite link discoverable HIGH Anyone joins workspace; full DM/channel access.
Vendor / supplier / e-procurement portal publicly exposed + breach corpus shows vendor accounts compromised HIGH Vendor impersonation + procurement fraud (BEC vector); regulatory exposure if PII/payment data flows.
Job-application / careers portal collects PII over plain HTTP (no TLS) HIGH Cleartext PII at scale; regulatory exposure under GDPR / CCPA / India DPDP Act / LGPD.
Decommissioned legacy mail (NXDOMAIN today) + breach corpus has historical employee URLs against it + cloud SSO migration confirmed via autodiscover IPs CRITICAL Stolen passwords almost certainly survived migration via reuse; SSO_EXPOSURE escalates regardless of the legacy host being dead.
Public-facing intranet (intranet.<domain> resolves and returns content without VPN) MEDIUM Internal-staff portal exposed; often leaks org structure, employee directory, internal apps.
Staging / preprod / UAT / sandbox subdomain publicly resolvable MEDIUM Often weaker auth, debug endpoints, test creds; sometimes mirrors prod data.
vpn.<domain> resolves but vendor + version unknown (passive only) INFO Attack surface flag only; escalate to HIGH-CRITICAL after active fingerprint matches a KEV CVE (§16.16).
DMARC RUA points to a third-party reporting vendor (kdmarc / dmarcian / Valimail / Agari / EasyDMARC) INFO Tenant signal only; vendor compromise = DMARC bypass for all their customers.